Guide · For the trade
Machine made rugs vs handmade: how to tell them apart and which to specify where
Machine made rugs are woven on a power loom, Wilton or Axminster, at yards per hour, with the pattern controlled by a computer and the fiber usually polypropylene, polyester, nylon or wool; handmade rugs are hand-knotted, hand-tufted or hand-loomed, one at a time, over days to months. On the floor the differences are the back, the edges, the fringe and the repeat: a machine made rug has a perfectly regular back, machine-serged edges, sewn-on or no fringe and a repeat that matches exactly. Machine made is the right spec for dining rooms, family rooms, rentals, hospitality and any room with dogs; handmade is for the living room and bedroom the client will keep for twenty years.
This guide is for the designer deciding how much of a rug budget goes to hand work and for the junior who has to say whether a sample is handmade. It covers what power loomed rugs are, the four checks on a sample, the comparison in numbers and where each belongs; the hand-knotted rugs guide covers the handmade side in depth.
What machine made and power loomed mean
Power loomed and machine woven are the same thing. A Wilton loom weaves the pile yarn into the backing as the rug is made, carrying unused colors along the back, so the pile is locked in. An Axminster loom inserts each tuft from pre-arranged spools and locks it with the weft, which allows an unlimited palette and is the construction behind most machine made Persian and Oriental patterns. The better machine made wool rugs from Couristan and Stanton are dense, heavy and long-lived. Our machine-woven filter holds 877 styles, 335 in polypropylene, 185 in polyester, 130 in wool and 81 in wool blends. Wilton and Axminster broadloom, 12 ft to 15 ft wide, adds a further route: cut and bound to any size in 3 to 5 weeks.
How to tell if a rug is handmade: four checks on the sample
- Turn it over. On a hand-knotted rug the design shows on the back as individual knots, slightly uneven, with the warp visible between rows. On a machine made rug the back is uniform, often with a visible grid and on a Wilton the back shows the colors carried along in bars. A cloth or canvas backing means hand-tufted or hand-loomed, not knotted.
- Look at the fringe. Hand-knotted fringe is the warp threads continuing out of the rug. Machine made fringe is sewn or glued on as a separate strip, or there is none. Hand-tufted and hand-loomed rugs have no fringe unless it is sewn.
- Check the edges. Handmade edges are overcast by hand and vary slightly; machine made edges are serged in a perfectly even stitch.
- Compare the repeats. On a machine made rug they match exactly; on a hand-knotted rug the motifs differ a little in size and spacing and a medallion is rarely perfectly centered.
Price is the fifth check: a hand-knotted 8x10 at a machine made price is not hand-knotted, whatever the tag says.
Machine made vs handmade, in numbers
| Construction | Time to make a 9x12 | Usual fibers | Pile height | Expected life | Custom sizes | Where it belongs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Machine woven, polypropylene or polyester | Under an hour | Polypropylene, polyester | 1/4 to 1/2 in | 5 to 10 years | Line sizes; some mills weave custom | Dining rooms, family rooms, rentals, kids' rooms, pets |
| Machine woven, wool | Under an hour | Wool, wool and nylon | 1/4 to 1/2 in | 15 to 20 years | Line sizes, broadloom bound to any size | Living rooms, halls, hospitality, stairs |
| Hand loomed | Days | Wool, wool blends, viscose | 1/4 to 3/4 in | 10 to 15 years | Easy, 8 to 14 weeks | Bedrooms, living rooms, textured solids |
| Hand tufted | Days | Wool, wool blends | 3/8 to 3/4 in | 7 to 12 years | Easy, 8 to 14 weeks | Bedrooms, living rooms, designs with curves |
| Hand knotted | Months | Wool, wool and silk | 1/4 to 1/2 in | Decades, often generations | Full custom, 18 to 20 weeks | Living rooms, primary bedrooms, the rug the client keeps |
Where machine made rugs are the right spec
A dining room with children: a machine woven polypropylene in a washed Persian pattern cleans with water and does not mind a dragged chair. A family room with dogs: the same, or a solution-dyed polyester. A rental, a beach house, a mudroom, a covered porch: polypropylene, the fiber in 140 of our 203 indoor-outdoor styles. A hotel corridor or a restaurant: machine woven wool or wool-nylon Axminster. The honest limit is hand and depth: a machine made rug has a flatter, more uniform surface and it does not age into anything; it wears out and gets replaced.
Where handmade is worth the money
The living room rug under the main seating group, the primary bedroom, the study and any room where the rug is the design. A hand-knotted wool rug develops a patina, can be rewashed and repaired for decades and holds its value; a hand-loomed or hand-tufted wool rug costs a fraction of that and gives the depth of wool in a solid or a texture. The practical split on most projects is handmade in the two or three rooms the client lives in, machine made everywhere feet, food and pets go; the what drives rug cost guide sets out the price ladder.
Machine made Persian and Oriental rugs: how to use them
The washed and tonal Persian patterns in the Oushak and Persian pattern collection are made both ways and the machine woven versions from Couristan are the ones to specify where a hand-knotted rug would be damaged. Choose wool or a heavy polypropylene, a low pile of 1/4 to 3/8 inch so chairs slide and a faded or absent border so the rug can run under furniture. Put a hand-knotted rug in the adjacent living room and the house reads as one scheme at two budgets.
Questions designers ask
How can you tell if a rug is handmade or machine made?
Turn it over. Knots visible on the back, warp-thread fringe, hand-overcast edges and slightly irregular repeats mean hand-knotted. A uniform grid on the back, sewn-on fringe and perfectly matching repeats mean machine made. A cloth backing means hand-tufted or hand-loomed.
Are machine made rugs good quality?
The better ones are. A dense machine woven wool Wilton or Axminster lasts 15 to 20 years and is the standard for hospitality; a heavy polypropylene lasts 5 to 10 and is the right rug for a room with spills. The weak ones are the thin, light ones; read the pile weight on the sheet.
Can a machine made rug be made in a custom size?
Some mills weave custom sizes on a Wilton or Axminster program in 8 to 16 weeks and any Wilton or Axminster broadloom can be cut and bound to size in 3 to 5 weeks. A full custom hand-knotted rug is 18 to 20 weeks after the strike-off.
Which rugs are machine made in the USA?
Milliken's tufted rugs and most domestic broadloom are made in the United States; the majority of machine woven Wilton and Axminster rugs, including many from Couristan and are woven in Belgium, Turkey, Egypt and India. The spec sheet lists the country of origin and we can filter a list by it on request.
Browse: machine-woven rugs · hand-knotted rugs · hand-loomed rugsWilton vs Axminster guide